Entertainment Weekly (No. 809, p.73) - "[An] earthy tribute to America's first great professional songwriter..." - Grade: B+
Though Stephen Foster died in 1864, his songs have remained part of the essential fabric of American culture. But even while most people can hum the melodies to "Camptown Races" and "Oh! Susanna," not many recognize Foster's name. BEAUTIFUL DREAMER, a tribute album that gives life to 18 of songwriter's most enduring compositions, may rectify that situation. The collection showcases Foster's witty, indelibly catchy tunes in inventive, diverse cover versions by an eclectic array of contemporary artists.
Raul Malo gives voice to the lilting title track, while Alison Krauss and Yo-Yo Ma team up for a near-ambient treatment of the lullaby "Slumber My Darling." The Duhks turn in a calypso-touched version of "Camptown Races," and John Prine's ragged, weary version of "My Old Kentucky Home, Goodnight" suits the song's haunting sense of nostalgia. Roger McGuinn's chiming, Byrds-esque take on "Jeanie with the Light Brown Hair" keeps things varied, but the highlight might be Mavis Staples's inspired, gospelized reading of "Hard Times Come Again No More." The proceeds from the album go to American Roots Publishing (a non-profit organization that preserves rural American culture and art). All told, the project is a fitting tribute to one of the great-grandfathers of American song.